What I Learned From My Family's Home Health Experience - Health Affairs

COVID-19 has opened the floodgates for health care at home options. Public health emergency waivers are fast-tracking telehealth and hospital at home—which provides hospital-level care in patients' homes—while infection concerns have driven more patients to home health following a hospitalization. These services and models are part of a growing list of home-based medical care models that also includes in-home primary or palliative care, in-home dialysis, and paramedicine. Some are covered through traditional Medicare, and others are available only through Medicare Advantage plans.

For patients, payers, and health policy professionals like me, the health care at home promise is tantalizing. In its ideal state, it would take fixed capital costs out of health care and redeploy them into person-centered care plans that include the diverse services and supports that individuals with complex care most need. It would also help patients and their families avoid the grueling and sometimes dangerous experience of an institutional setting.

But my recent experience managing home health and hospice for my father has given me insights into the perils that patients and their family caregivers could also face. Before we can migrate more health care into the home, we need to take a hard look at our performance with the current Medicare home-based benefits: home health and hospice. My own experience supporting my 83-year-old father, who is living with two serious illnesses, suggests we have a long way to go before our payment systems and benefit design are seriously up to the task. Below, I share the lessons and insights I gained in that process.

Service Coordination Is Essential To Making Home-Based Health Care Work

One of the benefits of a hospital room is that services and providers can easily visit the patient, meals arrive, nurses check in regularly, the physicians round. It's an institution and, as such, can be disorganized—no question—but it can also be efficient.  

What I realized, in arranging care at home for my father, is that scheduling home visits is a lot of work. And to manage that work, home health agencies commonly ask their clinical staff to "self-schedule," a practice through which each individual clinical staff person gets in touch with the patient or caregiver directly to set up the visit. It seems practical, but it also leaves the patient or caregiver to serve a centralizing function among many different service providers.

This approach to scheduling created a lot of chaos in our house. Our phone was ringing constantly. We frequently experienced overlapping appointments between nurses and therapists. Often, we received little to no advance notice before a service provider arrived at our door. On at least two occasions, the physical therapist called to say he "was in the area and wanted to stop by in 10 minutes," during the same window we were expecting a nurse. I had to call each of them separately to work it out.  

Throughout, all I could think was—if we "move health care home," without appropriate solutions (human and digital) for service coordination, we're going to turn family caregivers and patients into switchboard operators. What if I also had to juggle scheduling aide services, meals, or transportation; services delivered under new models that promise to address social determinants of health? It would be impossible.  

Families Need Appropriate Training And Support, Especially For Clinical Tasks

Over many years of talking to family caregivers, I've grown used to hearing them say some version of "I shouldn't be in charge of all this," in reference to the many clinical demands they face. I heard this again from my 81-year-old mother as we struggled to flush a PICC line for the first time. The hospital nurse who inserted the line told us that flushing it was "easy" when he did a brief demonstration. However, health care providers forget that a woman in her eighties (or one in her fifties for that matter) will forget details and struggle to manipulate tiny plastic clamps and caps. When our home health nurse didn't show up, we relied on YouTube to get us through it.

Separate from home health, an oxygen company delivered three tanks and a large, heavy machine and tubes. Late one night, I found my mother dragging the big machine across the living room floor so she could give my dad oxygen in bed. She was panicking because his oxygen level was dropping, which, it turns out, is normal at night—just no one had told us to expect that.

We are happy to perform medical tasks if it means avoiding a hospital admission. But what seems easy to clinicians is not easy to the many caregivers who are older adults themselves. And if the caregiver also experiences limitations or has language or cultural barriers, it becomes dangerous for everyone. It is hard to even imagine what my mother would have done if there were more machines and devices or more medical needs. Without the appropriate assistance, training, and oversight, she'd have been completely overwhelmed.  

Coverage Decisions Should Reflect Individual Patient Needs

In many respects, my father is a perfect candidate for health care at home. He is medically complex and homebound, with good secondary insurance and lots of family support. Nevertheless, the hospice and home health benefits were a poor fit for his needs.  

A year ago, my father was diagnosed with Myelodysplastic Syndrome, which is a serious disorder that disrupts the production of blood cells. Despite ceasing curative care and being near the end of life, my father was unable to access the hospice benefit. Two different hospice agencies—one a nonprofit and one a large for-profit—told me that hospice "wouldn't cover" the frequent blood transfusions my father needs to manage his symptoms. So, we decided to forgo hospice rather than compromise his comfort and hasten his death.

At the same time, the rules guiding the Medicare home health benefit along with standard agency practices prevented us from accessing skilled nursing visits and other services at the frequency and cadence necessary to best support my dad and my mother. As someone who has read these rules many times in a professional capacity, I found them impenetrable when reading from a beneficiary perspective. To qualify for coverage, the beneficiary's need for skilled care must be intermittent, meaning "needed or given on fewer than seven days each week or less than eight hours each day over a period of 21 days (or less)." Once deemed eligible, the benefit covers "part-time or intermittent" skilled nursing or home health aide services, which is defined as "services combined to total less than 8 hours per day and 28 or fewer hours each week." 

As a practical matter, all three of the home health agencies I called were quick to tell me that the benefit does not provide daily skilled nursing care. Perhaps, we didn't need daily skilled care, but it was curious that all three agencies emphasized this constraint. We ended up getting one skilled nursing visit a week, which is probably fine with my mother providing full-time care but would have been wholly inadequate without her there.

Within several weeks following his hospital stay, we had one assessment, one skilled nursing visit, and one physical therapy visit. Policy makers have been so confused about the purpose of the home health benefit and so consumed with concerns about fraud and abuse to the point that it's not much help. What would have really been helpful? A nurse who could have helped us quarterback the many clinical interactions and decisions we needed to make; someone to help manage the information necessary to engage with physicians and hospital staff; a partner to my mother in managing my father's care needs, not just more disconnected clinical services.  

Much of my dad's health care occurs in medical offices. It would be great if more of it came to him, but not if, because of problematic payment incentives, it means sacrificing access to benefits to which he is entitled. I worry that policy makers lack the payment reform and quality improvement tools necessary to ensure access and meet individual patient medical needs at home.  

The Future Of Health Care At Home

The Medicare home health and hospice benefits are not the same as primary care at home or hospital at home models. But as the latter two increasingly become included as plan benefits, and as we work to improve the former, policy makers should keep in mind that organizing and delivering services at home can create challenges for patients and their families. The home setting, more than any other, requires that we:

  • Fund and value good coordination and accountability for service delivery;
  • Equip patients and family members to perform medical tasks, according to their preferences and abilities; and
  • Ensure that the varied services and supports are delivered in the appropriate amount, mix, and cadence to meet the needs of all patients.

Based on my personal and professional experiences, I do not think an "episode of care" should serve as the basis of payment for health care at home, as it does today for home health. After all, it's one thing to pay for a 3–5-day episode of inpatient care in a hospital setting. It's a whole other matter to pay a flat rate for 30 days of care delivered in someone's home. A lot can happen in that time, and payment tied only to a set period of time can perpetuate problems with silo-based fee-for-service care. 

As we move forward in designing new payment systems for health care at home, there must be an entity—such as a primary care organization, for example—with annualized accountability for delivering high-value care in the home, even if the care is delivered and financed episodically. And furthermore, these accountable entities must have some flexibility in determining the types, mix, and cadence of services. They must also be accountable for care coordination and integration across services and providers.

The most logical place to look for these innovations would be in the primary care groups operating under value-based payment in Medicare Advantage. In reality, though, even those groups I talk to report challenges working with home health agencies to deliver a more flexible and person-centered service. And, of course, Medicare Advantage members' caregivers tell me that the prior authorization requirements and utilization management only elevate the hassles and challenges I have experienced.

My family was, of course, fortunate in many ways, including our financial circumstances and knowledge of how the system is supposed to work. And, despite the challenges, I observed incredible professionalism and compassion among clinicians and administrative staff. That our health care system is staffed with such extraordinary people fills me with the greatest optimism and hope for the work we all do. Good people will figure out a way, but we need to help them by designing benefits and payment systems to better support well-coordinated care for vulnerable individuals.

Comments